fs 2024 Vanilla Turbine Failure With No Blacksquare Failure
-
The two engine condition numbers are not connected at all, but the MSFS 2024 engine failure event acts on the simulation the same way as triggering an engine failure from my tablet. If you trigger an engine failure from my tablet, you will also see the displayed condition remain at 100%. I choose to interpret this as the extremely rare (in PT6's) fluke engine shutdown, which remains unexplained, even after the aircraft is inspected, and had nothing to do with improper operation.
-
@Black-Square So the solution is to turn off FS2024 default engine damage?
@Buzz As you've probably seen in my FAQ, you need the engine damage option enable, in order for my failure system to trigger a complete engine failure, but MSFS should not just be triggering random catastrophic engine failures.
-
I also experienced a seemingly random engine failure, on my first "full" flight (had only messed around w/ the aircraft for maybe 10-15 min prior) and about 30 minutes or so into this flight, with proper operation, a "default" MSFS 2024 engine failure occurred, seemingly without any reason. Just wanted to confirm - is it a bug? Or is it "supposed" to have this random failure? Thanks in advance! Loving the Caravan so far.
-
@Black-Square
Nick, the Caravan is consistently chewing away at the condition of the default FS2024 Turbine engine.I just did a test with the Wear and Tear window open and as long as the caravan engine is running, the wear and tear value is decreasing regardless of where the engine is operating at.
Steps to test:
- Load caravan on the ground cold and dark..
- Turn on fs2024 Dev mode, goto Debug/Aircraft/Wear and Tear
- Move the wear and tear window to another screen to view..
- Normal startup on caravan, taxi, takeoff, climbout and cruise.
- Note the Turbine engine condition in the fs2024 W&T window decreasing until it gets to zero triggering a catastrophic failure.
-
@Black-Square
Nick, the Caravan is consistently chewing away at the condition of the default FS2024 Turbine engine.I just did a test with the Wear and Tear window open and as long as the caravan engine is running, the wear and tear value is decreasing regardless of where the engine is operating at.
Steps to test:
- Load caravan on the ground cold and dark..
- Turn on fs2024 Dev mode, goto Debug/Aircraft/Wear and Tear
- Move the wear and tear window to another screen to view..
- Normal startup on caravan, taxi, takeoff, climbout and cruise.
- Note the Turbine engine condition in the fs2024 W&T window decreasing until it gets to zero triggering a catastrophic failure.
@Buzz Very interesting... I just did all of this exactly earlier, and found no problem, then let the simulator run for about two hours with no problem. Can you also tell me which variant you just tested with, just so there is no chance for error?
-
@Buzz Very interesting... I just did all of this exactly earlier, and found no problem, then let the simulator run for about two hours with no problem. Can you also tell me which variant you just tested with, just so there is no chance for error?
@Black-Square The FedEx Livery of the cargomaster. Failures at 1x in MTBF mode
-
B Buzz referenced this topic
-
B Buzz referenced this topic
-
And even under active or static pause while the sim is stopped, the W&T keeps decreasing.
Using the "Modern" flight model, with these settings .
@Buzz Thank you for the screenshot of your setting page! It's not the engine damage option, it's the airframe damage! Another completely sensical behavior from MSFS 2024!
I saw a post on the developer forums a while ago about spontaneous failures due to the simulator using the incorrect configuration speed for this mysterious "airframe damage", which I imagine is related. The damage begins as soon as the propeller is spinning, even before the engine is started.
Now we just need to find what undocumented configuration value is being used to determine that a propeller RPM of 0.0001 should damage the ""airframe"". More to come...
-
@Buzz Thank you for the screenshot of your setting page! It's not the engine damage option, it's the airframe damage! Another completely sensical behavior from MSFS 2024!
I saw a post on the developer forums a while ago about spontaneous failures due to the simulator using the incorrect configuration speed for this mysterious "airframe damage", which I imagine is related. The damage begins as soon as the propeller is spinning, even before the engine is started.
Now we just need to find what undocumented configuration value is being used to determine that a propeller RPM of 0.0001 should damage the ""airframe"". More to come...
@Black-Square Copy. I need to run to work, but will be back later today after my flight. Let me know if there is anything I can help test.
Cheers
-
@Buzz Thank you for the screenshot of your setting page! It's not the engine damage option, it's the airframe damage! Another completely sensical behavior from MSFS 2024!
I saw a post on the developer forums a while ago about spontaneous failures due to the simulator using the incorrect configuration speed for this mysterious "airframe damage", which I imagine is related. The damage begins as soon as the propeller is spinning, even before the engine is started.
Now we just need to find what undocumented configuration value is being used to determine that a propeller RPM of 0.0001 should damage the ""airframe"". More to come...
@Black-Square said in fs 2024 Vanilla Turbine Failure With No Blacksquare Failure:
Now we just need to find what undocumented configuration value is being used to determine that a propeller RPM of 0.0001 should damage the ""airframe"". More to come...
Thats odd since it's actually the "Engine Health" that's decreasing, not anything related to the airframe.
-
@Black-Square said in fs 2024 Vanilla Turbine Failure With No Blacksquare Failure:
Now we just need to find what undocumented configuration value is being used to determine that a propeller RPM of 0.0001 should damage the ""airframe"". More to come...
Thats odd since it's actually the "Engine Health" that's decreasing, not anything related to the airframe.
@Buzz said in fs 2024 Vanilla Turbine Failure With No Blacksquare Failure:
Thats odd
You're telling me.
-
No, I take it all back. If you open the other drop-downs in your Wear and Tear debugger, I think you will see that all the aircraft's components are being degraded at the same time and the same rate, as soon as the propeller is spinning. It indicates that a failure would not be expected for ~120 hours, though (yikes, what is this wear and tear system?) Did you ever see the TURBINE_ENGINE health declining at a rate faster than in the default aircraft? I think what I'm seeing right now is just how this default wear and tear systems is supposed to function.
EDIT: Yes, I see the same behavior with the default TBM. Also, the condition keeps declining after you exit the flight and you're in the main menu...
Sorry for the false alarm, everyone. I've become very sleep deprived while working on this tonight.
-
Here is a post on the Official Forums that seems to be at the intersection of what's being described here. Last post 19 hours ago. If anyone wants to engage, let me know what you can learn. I have already invested a substantial amount of time in this, but I would still rather is be a MSFS 2024 fluke than something I neglected.
-
@Black-Square So shutting off Airframe damage should solve the issue?
-
Ooh, reading that post linked above, are people who are seeing this on SU4 or the SU5 beta? I cannot contribute a data point because I have aircraft and airframe stress damage off by default, but also despite owning the Caravan since day 1 I have been unable to find flying time this week, so I'm waiting until 1.1 drops next week.
