Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Users
Collapse
Just Flight Community Forum
  1. Home
  2. Just Flight
  3. MSFS Products
  4. Black Square Add-Ons
  5. TBM 850
  6. Echo19 TBM850 Coming Soon!

Echo19 TBM850 Coming Soon!

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved TBM 850
77 Posts 30 Posters 6.4k Views 2 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

    I've just done my first flight with this sound pack and, well, I feel like I'm really missing something that everyone else is hearing. I mean, the engine sounds better I guess even though it sounds grossly different from the TBMs I fly. Ok I can put it down to prop I suppose but the whine is different, the start is different, idle is different, and so on. And where are the little personality sounds around the cockpit? Where is the clack clack of the trim, the buzz of the flaps, the distinctly loud fuel pump, or the overpoweringly loud heater? I mean, a few of those things are sort of there but so very quiet. Is there a modded option to this sound pack I'm missing?

    echo19tylerE Offline
    echo19tylerE Offline
    echo19tyler
    wrote last edited by echo19tyler
    #68

    @CdnCptMoustache

    You must not have it installed correctly, or the pack isn't functioning as intended, because essentially all of those things are included in the pack. Have you watched our before and after video and does it align with your sim?

    CdnCptMoustacheC 1 Reply Last reply
    1
    • echo19tylerE echo19tyler

      @CdnCptMoustache

      You must not have it installed correctly, or the pack isn't functioning as intended, because essentially all of those things are included in the pack. Have you watched our before and after video and does it align with your sim?

      CdnCptMoustacheC Online
      CdnCptMoustacheC Online
      CdnCptMoustache
      wrote last edited by
      #69

      @echo19tyler I bought/installed it through Contrail. Interestingly enough, I had to uninstall and reinstall it once as on first load I had the GPS-behind-the-plane bug. I've tried a few more reinstalls to see about fixing the results below but no changes.

      Once I got it working, it follows in that I hear the same sounds as in the video but only if I really crank up my headphone volume*, and balance isn't correct at all. Flaps, for example, should be heard clearly over the engine and they aren't. The auto-fuel-switching should be inaudible over the engine but in this version it's louder than the flaps. The high pitched whine in the engine is highly over-done to the point that I feel like I'd go crazy if I listened to that for a flight. Also, I still have no clack clack on the electric trim which led me into a bit of a Youtube deep dive to see if the 850 even has the same trim setup I'm used to and it does. Yes, I've got noise cancelling off and I've played with my in-sim volume sliders but nothing I do gives me even a remote feeling of being in a TBM, sound-wise, and for the price I'm very disappointed.

      *I notice you also crank up your volume for the "after" in the video as ambient/environmental sounds are far louder than in the before. I'm not going to go so far as to call it false advertising but it's certainly a bit misleading and I didn't notice this until a repeated rewatch

      echo19tylerE 1 Reply Last reply
      1
      • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

        @echo19tyler I bought/installed it through Contrail. Interestingly enough, I had to uninstall and reinstall it once as on first load I had the GPS-behind-the-plane bug. I've tried a few more reinstalls to see about fixing the results below but no changes.

        Once I got it working, it follows in that I hear the same sounds as in the video but only if I really crank up my headphone volume*, and balance isn't correct at all. Flaps, for example, should be heard clearly over the engine and they aren't. The auto-fuel-switching should be inaudible over the engine but in this version it's louder than the flaps. The high pitched whine in the engine is highly over-done to the point that I feel like I'd go crazy if I listened to that for a flight. Also, I still have no clack clack on the electric trim which led me into a bit of a Youtube deep dive to see if the 850 even has the same trim setup I'm used to and it does. Yes, I've got noise cancelling off and I've played with my in-sim volume sliders but nothing I do gives me even a remote feeling of being in a TBM, sound-wise, and for the price I'm very disappointed.

        *I notice you also crank up your volume for the "after" in the video as ambient/environmental sounds are far louder than in the before. I'm not going to go so far as to call it false advertising but it's certainly a bit misleading and I didn't notice this until a repeated rewatch

        echo19tylerE Offline
        echo19tylerE Offline
        echo19tyler
        wrote last edited by
        #70

        @CdnCptMoustache

        I appreciate you taking the time to explain further, and I’m sorry you aren’t having as good an experience with it. I’m curious: are you flying an 850 in real life, another TBM variant, or primarily comparing it with your simulator experience? It would help to understand your reference point.

        We’ve had several current and former 850 pilots give us a ton of feedback and help shape the overall soundscape. Not to mention, again, that we've recorded two separate TBM 850s for this project. That feedback informed the balance we’ve chosen, though I appreciate that what you’re hearing doesn’t match your expectations.

        Regarding the fuel selector and flaps, the flaps are barely audible in the real aircraft unless you’re at low idle/lower power settings, while the fuel selector is much more noticeable. The electric trim motor is also modeled, but it’s extremely quiet in real life, which is reflected in the pack.

        I don’t necessarily agree that the high-pitched whine is overdone, but I understand that you’re finding it uncomfortable. It’s a loud airplane, and that’s why we included noise cancellation/filtering as an option. Pilots wear headsets that reduce those harsher frequencies, and that option is intended to mirror the experience. Since you mentioned having it off, I’d suggest trying it enabled if it's bothering you - listening to a PT6 in real life without headphones on would also annoy me.

        Regarding volume, this is an entirely new soundscape, so some experimentation with overall volume and in-sim settings is expected to find what works best for your equipment and preferences. The levels you used with the original aircraft audio won’t necessarily produce the same listening experience with this pack, as you've already discovered.

        Thanks for giving it a shot and taking the time to share your experience.

        CdnCptMoustacheC 1 Reply Last reply
        1
        • echo19tylerE echo19tyler

          @CdnCptMoustache

          I appreciate you taking the time to explain further, and I’m sorry you aren’t having as good an experience with it. I’m curious: are you flying an 850 in real life, another TBM variant, or primarily comparing it with your simulator experience? It would help to understand your reference point.

          We’ve had several current and former 850 pilots give us a ton of feedback and help shape the overall soundscape. Not to mention, again, that we've recorded two separate TBM 850s for this project. That feedback informed the balance we’ve chosen, though I appreciate that what you’re hearing doesn’t match your expectations.

          Regarding the fuel selector and flaps, the flaps are barely audible in the real aircraft unless you’re at low idle/lower power settings, while the fuel selector is much more noticeable. The electric trim motor is also modeled, but it’s extremely quiet in real life, which is reflected in the pack.

          I don’t necessarily agree that the high-pitched whine is overdone, but I understand that you’re finding it uncomfortable. It’s a loud airplane, and that’s why we included noise cancellation/filtering as an option. Pilots wear headsets that reduce those harsher frequencies, and that option is intended to mirror the experience. Since you mentioned having it off, I’d suggest trying it enabled if it's bothering you - listening to a PT6 in real life without headphones on would also annoy me.

          Regarding volume, this is an entirely new soundscape, so some experimentation with overall volume and in-sim settings is expected to find what works best for your equipment and preferences. The levels you used with the original aircraft audio won’t necessarily produce the same listening experience with this pack, as you've already discovered.

          Thanks for giving it a shot and taking the time to share your experience.

          CdnCptMoustacheC Online
          CdnCptMoustacheC Online
          CdnCptMoustache
          wrote last edited by
          #71

          @echo19tyler I fly a TBM-960 and am one of the most experienced pilots in this plane in the country. I have experience in all weather and virtually all conditions in an emergency-services capacity. In our training for our extreme conditions, we routinely take these planes to the outer edges of the envelope in all directions so it's not just me bragging when I say that I see, hear, and experience things that most pilots, and particularly TBM pilots, don't. In addition, I have compared the 850 to 960 in videos and have been in communication with coworkers with experience on that specific type to ask. I had some great chats with them while sitting around this summer and the end result is, sound-wise, they are almost identical IRL. You notice a small change in how the prop sound behaves due to the difference between 4 and 5 blades but that's not huge.

          So please understand that I come from a place of great experience when I say that in a few of your points, I very much disagree. The flaps are plainly audible in all phases of flight, including up to 175 knots and max power. Tested and confirmed IRL. The trim motor is not but the electric trim clutch kicking in is the Clack Clack I'm referring to, and it's completely missing (hence the comments about the trim deep-dive in my last reply). IRL the automatic fuel selector is completely inaudible inflight unless you're at idle and slow speed. And so on.

          re: the PT-6 being "very loud" IRL, I spent 17 years flying Turbo Commanders with twin Garretts. A single PT-6 by comparison is pleasant, smooth, and devoid of the same high-pitched whine I'm hearing with this sound pack in the sim. Coming from years of twin Garretts, I'd have no issue flying the TBM with no headset if forced to by circumstance. The sim's noise cancelling is not an option as there's no noise cancelling in the world (including the brand new Bose A30s that come with the TBM) that works half as well as what we have in the sim and it's just not realistic to me.

          echo19tylerE 1 Reply Last reply
          1
          • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

            @echo19tyler I fly a TBM-960 and am one of the most experienced pilots in this plane in the country. I have experience in all weather and virtually all conditions in an emergency-services capacity. In our training for our extreme conditions, we routinely take these planes to the outer edges of the envelope in all directions so it's not just me bragging when I say that I see, hear, and experience things that most pilots, and particularly TBM pilots, don't. In addition, I have compared the 850 to 960 in videos and have been in communication with coworkers with experience on that specific type to ask. I had some great chats with them while sitting around this summer and the end result is, sound-wise, they are almost identical IRL. You notice a small change in how the prop sound behaves due to the difference between 4 and 5 blades but that's not huge.

            So please understand that I come from a place of great experience when I say that in a few of your points, I very much disagree. The flaps are plainly audible in all phases of flight, including up to 175 knots and max power. Tested and confirmed IRL. The trim motor is not but the electric trim clutch kicking in is the Clack Clack I'm referring to, and it's completely missing (hence the comments about the trim deep-dive in my last reply). IRL the automatic fuel selector is completely inaudible inflight unless you're at idle and slow speed. And so on.

            re: the PT-6 being "very loud" IRL, I spent 17 years flying Turbo Commanders with twin Garretts. A single PT-6 by comparison is pleasant, smooth, and devoid of the same high-pitched whine I'm hearing with this sound pack in the sim. Coming from years of twin Garretts, I'd have no issue flying the TBM with no headset if forced to by circumstance. The sim's noise cancelling is not an option as there's no noise cancelling in the world (including the brand new Bose A30s that come with the TBM) that works half as well as what we have in the sim and it's just not realistic to me.

            echo19tylerE Offline
            echo19tylerE Offline
            echo19tyler
            wrote last edited by
            #72

            @CdnCptMoustache

            Thanks for clarifying your background. I respect your experience with the 960, and I appreciate you explaining the specific differences you’re hearing.

            You’re right about the trim clutch; that’s a valid criticism. We had difficulty recreating that sound because the information available to us in the sim doesn’t let us distinguish between autopilot-driven trim and pilot input.

            I do disagree with your assessment that the four- and five-blade configurations sound almost identical. Hartzell even describes its five-blade TBM conversion as significantly quieter inside the cabin and outside the aircraft. Capturing the four-blade 850’s distinct sound was one of the reasons we wanted to make this pack in the first place. Your experience in the 960 is relevant, but comparisons with the aircraft we’re representing need to account for those differences. The same distinction matters when comparing the legacy 850 with the 930 audio used by earlier BKSQ 850 versions.

            One clarification regarding filtering: I was referring to the pack’s separate function activated by clicking the headphone jack. That’s independent of the simulator’s built-in filtering, so we may have been talking about two different things.

            Regarding the wider soundscape, we’ve drawn on my own professional experience working around dozens of airframes, detailed feedback from current and former 850 pilots, and input from the broader community. Your feedback deserves consideration within that picture, but I’d ask that those other firsthand observations receive the same consideration, even where they differ from yours.

            I recognize that the final mix won’t match every listener’s expectations. That doesn’t make your feedback unwelcome, but a disagreement doesn’t automatically mean the choices are inaccurate. I’m willing to acknowledge shortcomings and reconsider our conclusions, as with the trim clutch, and I’d appreciate the same openness as we consider the experience behind our other decisions.

            I appreciate your support and the time you’ve taken to explain your concerns.

            CdnCptMoustacheC 1 Reply Last reply
            1
            • echo19tylerE echo19tyler

              @CdnCptMoustache

              Thanks for clarifying your background. I respect your experience with the 960, and I appreciate you explaining the specific differences you’re hearing.

              You’re right about the trim clutch; that’s a valid criticism. We had difficulty recreating that sound because the information available to us in the sim doesn’t let us distinguish between autopilot-driven trim and pilot input.

              I do disagree with your assessment that the four- and five-blade configurations sound almost identical. Hartzell even describes its five-blade TBM conversion as significantly quieter inside the cabin and outside the aircraft. Capturing the four-blade 850’s distinct sound was one of the reasons we wanted to make this pack in the first place. Your experience in the 960 is relevant, but comparisons with the aircraft we’re representing need to account for those differences. The same distinction matters when comparing the legacy 850 with the 930 audio used by earlier BKSQ 850 versions.

              One clarification regarding filtering: I was referring to the pack’s separate function activated by clicking the headphone jack. That’s independent of the simulator’s built-in filtering, so we may have been talking about two different things.

              Regarding the wider soundscape, we’ve drawn on my own professional experience working around dozens of airframes, detailed feedback from current and former 850 pilots, and input from the broader community. Your feedback deserves consideration within that picture, but I’d ask that those other firsthand observations receive the same consideration, even where they differ from yours.

              I recognize that the final mix won’t match every listener’s expectations. That doesn’t make your feedback unwelcome, but a disagreement doesn’t automatically mean the choices are inaccurate. I’m willing to acknowledge shortcomings and reconsider our conclusions, as with the trim clutch, and I’d appreciate the same openness as we consider the experience behind our other decisions.

              I appreciate your support and the time you’ve taken to explain your concerns.

              CdnCptMoustacheC Online
              CdnCptMoustacheC Online
              CdnCptMoustache
              wrote last edited by
              #73

              I was going to counter a lot of the things you've said but changed my mind. I'd happily take a refund

              A echo19tylerE 2 Replies Last reply
              2
              • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

                I was going to counter a lot of the things you've said but changed my mind. I'd happily take a refund

                A Online
                A Online
                andyW2025
                wrote last edited by
                #74

                @CdnCptMoustache I already tried for a refund. They won’t allow it.

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

                  I was going to counter a lot of the things you've said but changed my mind. I'd happily take a refund

                  echo19tylerE Offline
                  echo19tylerE Offline
                  echo19tyler
                  wrote last edited by
                  #75

                  @CdnCptMoustache

                  I’m sorry the pack hasn’t met your expectations, and I appreciate you giving it a try.

                  If you’d still like to share reference recordings, you’re welcome to DM them here or via Discord. I’d be happy to listen and consider them alongside the other reference material and professional recordings we captured. We remain open to specific feedback that can help us improve the experience. 🙂

                  CdnCptMoustacheC 1 Reply Last reply
                  1
                  • echo19tylerE echo19tyler

                    @CdnCptMoustache

                    I’m sorry the pack hasn’t met your expectations, and I appreciate you giving it a try.

                    If you’d still like to share reference recordings, you’re welcome to DM them here or via Discord. I’d be happy to listen and consider them alongside the other reference material and professional recordings we captured. We remain open to specific feedback that can help us improve the experience. 🙂

                    CdnCptMoustacheC Online
                    CdnCptMoustacheC Online
                    CdnCptMoustache
                    wrote last edited by
                    #76

                    @echo19tyler I have no interest in that but I do really appreciate your offer to have me help out with your paid product. In the future I look forward to great improvements in order for this pack to sound a little more like a TBM. In the meantime I'll be satisfied to continue professionally flying professional TBMs in my professional career and happily take a refund for this product.

                    P 1 Reply Last reply
                    2
                    • CdnCptMoustacheC CdnCptMoustache

                      @echo19tyler I have no interest in that but I do really appreciate your offer to have me help out with your paid product. In the future I look forward to great improvements in order for this pack to sound a little more like a TBM. In the meantime I'll be satisfied to continue professionally flying professional TBMs in my professional career and happily take a refund for this product.

                      P Offline
                      P Offline
                      PeterT
                      wrote last edited by
                      #77

                      @CdnCptMoustache said in Echo19 TBM850 Coming Soon!:

                      In the meantime I'll be satisfied to continue professionally flying professional TBMs in my professional career

                      😂 😂 😂 😂 😂

                      Don't worry, GTA VI is out on Thursday.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      Reply
                      • Reply as topic
                      Log in to reply
                      • Oldest to Newest
                      • Newest to Oldest
                      • Most Votes


                      • Login

                      • Don't have an account? Register

                      • Login or register to search.
                      • First post
                        Last post
                      0
                      • Categories
                      • Recent
                      • Tags
                      • Popular
                      • Users