Clicking KX155B "Pull Ident" triggers NAV switch flip on audio panel
-
Is this prototypical or bug?
When you click the "PULL IDENT" knob on the KX155B or the KNS81, the appropriate NAV switch on the audio panel flips. So if you "pull" (well, click) the "PULL IDENT" knob of the NAV 1 radio, the NAV 1 switch on the audio panel flips.
I am wondering if this is how the real equipment works? I mean, does pulling a knob on the radio make the switch on the audio panel flip? Or is this a simplified behavior? Or a bug?
I am not familiar with how the real-world unit behaves but I find it surprising that an interaction with the "PULL IDENT" knob on the NAV radio triggers the switch on the audio panel.
What I expected is that both the "PULL IDENT" and the appropriate NAV switch on the audio panel needs to be manipulated individually by the pilot in order for the station identifier to be heard.
Also, I am not sure if the pulling (well, clicking) of the small adjustment knob is supposed to be animated but I do not see any movement of the knob when "pulled".
-
You are correct that both the knob and the switch should be actuated to hear the identifier in the real aircraft, but there is no convenient way for me to simulate this in an aircraft that also makes use of third party GPS systems. In other words, I could accomplish this myself, but since other GPS units already make use of the default NAV IDENT variable, there is no way for me to override their behavior, or at least not in an intuitive way.
-
Now that I noticed this behavior I cannot unsee it. You mentioned third party GPS already make use of the default NAV IDENT variable, which explains why you coded it this way. But could you make it more realistic when using one of the non-third party units?
For example, when using the "default" GNS 530/430 and/or your KX155B/KNS81 combo (the so-called no-GPS config), would it be possible to give us at least the option to disable to automatic flipping of the relevant switch on the audio panel (perhaps selectable via the tablet)? I'd love to click both the PULL IDENT and also the NAV 1 swtich on the audio panel myself, rather than having some "invisble" hand manipulating switches I never clicked. I love Black Square for the ultra realism, and the current solution, while understandable, does not match the level of detail of the rest of the systems.
First, the PULL IDENT click does not physically pull that knob, I'd love to see the knob animated. And second, clicking a static (non-animated) knob even triggers a different switch to physically move is kind of immersion-killing (for me). Please, at least for the default units (GNS 530/430 and your own KNS81), rework this to make it more realistic so that the pilot needs to click the PULL IDENT as well as the appropriate switch on the audio panel, rather than the NAV 1 switch moving by itself.
I hope it's something you can implement.
